K.C.'s resistance to moving back with his mother has him crashing and burning, and the person who helps pick up the pieces is the last person he expects. Clare's parents' marriage is on the rocks, just as her own love life is heating up. And Alli considers Drew to be her boyfriend, but that might be news to him.
The episode begins with K.C., Bianca and Fitz, hungover in a car. Jenna approaches them and talks to K.C. about his mom. During football practice, K.C. tackles the line backer, which is not allowed. Coach Armstrong asks K.C. if anything is wrong, though K.C. insists that things are fine. Armstrong tells K.C. that he is available if K.C. needs to talk. K.C. later talks to his mom about how bad it is for him to stay there and asks her not to take him away from the group home, once again, hurting his mother's feelings. K.C. needs references about staying at the group home. He goes to coach for help to which he says no. K.C. freaks out and without thinking, keys his car. K.C. tries to get Jenna to leave the school before he gets in trouble for keying Coach Armstrong's car, but he utterly fails and gets pulled into the office. His mother, social worker, coach, and principal talk to him. When everyone jumps to conclusions assuming that K.C. did everything, his mother (Lisa) stands up for her son and K.C. is impressed. Lisa is tired of trying to make the decision for him so she tells him that he can decide and if K.C. wants to stay at the group home, she'll acknowledge his decision. K.C. appears in his mother's apartment and this surprises her. K.C. has decided to live with his mom. After saying they missed each other, they share a beautiful, memorable moment.
Eli approaches Clare while she's at her locker saying he missed her and asking if the reason she didn't hang out with him is that Twilight was on, Clare quickly starts talking about her parents. Eli grabs her arm and says "Stop. rewind, and play." Clare continues talking about how her parents fight and how she wishes she wants to let her feelings all out. Eli finally convines Clare to write about it in her English assignment. In English, Clare and Eli get detention for skipping class even though Clare claims they were actually working. Ms. Dawes asks Clare to present her assignment that she worked on. Clare starts her assignment and in the middle, she starts breaking down. Clare apologizes and the teacher says she's heard enough and its a good start. As Ms. Dawes asks for Eli's opinion, Eli suggests she should read it at a bigger audience, such as the student showcase. Clare is flabbergasted and tells Eli that her mom's going to be there. Eli replies that it's what she wanted, to talk to her mother.Clare is nervous at the showcase when it's her turn to read her assignment. She gets cold feet while Eli continues to try to persuade her to read it, but Clare ignores it since it's very personal and leaves at the last minute. Clare's mom is confused why Clare suddenly bailed since she has never been like that. Clare gives her the paper she was about to read before have cold feet. She convinces her mom to confront her dad on what's going on. Clare is finally happy when she agrees and goes outside while they are talking. When she steps outside, she sees Eli arriving in his hearse at the front of her house. Eli says he will acknowledge her decision whether she tells her mother or not. She tells him that she read the letter to her mom and Eli makes a smug remark about how his plan worked. Eli apologizes for being so nosy and lets her borrow his headphones to block out the noise if anything gets crazy or his sarcastic remarks. He promises never to interfere and before driving off, Clare touches his hand to get his attention, stopping him, and says, "You can interfere once in a while, but I'm still gonna do what I want." Eli tells her that he wouldn't expect anything less, smirks, and drives off, leaving Clare grinning.
While in class, Alli is talking about her new boyfriend. Dave thinks it's him and Alli corrects him telling him it was Drew, making things awkward. Alli asks Drew if they wanna go on a date, and Drew rejects because he has a lot going on since its football season. Drew catches up with Alli later and asks if they could go hang out somewhere. Alli tells Drew that her parents won't be home for another hour.
Regular Cast (Ordered Alphabetically)
- Raymond Ablack as Sav Bhandari
- Luke Bilyk as Drew Torres
- Stefan Brogren as Archie Simpson
- Munro Chambers as Eli Goldsworthy
- Sam Earle as K.C. Guthrie
- Jahmil French as Dave Turner
- Alicia Josipovic as Bianca DeSousa
- Argiris Karras as Riley Stavros
- Cory Lee as Winnie Oh
- Aislinn Paul as Clare Edwards
- Melinda Shankar as Alli Bhandari
- Jessica Tyler as Jenna Middleton
- Paula Boudreau as Ms. Dawes
- Robin Brûlé as Lisa Guthrie
- Shannon Kook-Chun as Zane Park
- Ruth Marshall as Helen Edwards
- Joe Bostick as Todd
- James Edward Campbell as Mark Fitzgerald
- Daniel Kelly as Owen Milligan
- Michael Kinney as Darryl Armstrong
- Russell Yuen as Lawyer
- Charlotte Arnold as Holly J. Sinclair
- Annie Clark as Fiona Coyne
- Judy Jiao as Leia Chang
- Jamie Johnston as Peter Stone
- Landon Liboiron as Declan Coyne
- Jajube Mandiela as Chantay Black
- Samantha Munro as Anya MacPherson
- AJ Saudin as Connor Delaurier
- Jordan Todosey as Adam Torres
- Spencer Van Wyck as Wesley Betenkamp
- Eli: "Missed you last night. What, was Twilight on TV?"
- Eli: "Stop, rewind and.... play."
- Eli: "Wow, how did it feel to write this?" Clare: "Good, really good."
- (Eli hands Clare his headphones) Clare: "What are these for?" Eli: "In case things get worse with your folks. Or you need to ignore an English partner."
- Clare: "You can interfere every once in a while, but I'm still going to do what I want." Eli: "Wouldn't expect anything less."
- Eli: "Maybe your scared!" Clare: "Of what?" Eli: "Finding out what's really going on between your parents."
- Bianca: "You suffered a serious case of gin induced verbal diarrhea"
- Fitz: "Your basketball coach really hired a hooker? Cause I want on that team."
- "Better With You" by Five Times August - Heard when Eli shows up at Clare's doorstep.
- "Sunshine Singing" by The Pets - Heard when K.C. keys Coach Armstrong's car.
- Watch Better Off Alone (2) on GorillaVid (International)