Manny had a crush on Sully, but was told that he only liked "hot" girls, and that Manny herself was "adorable". To fix this, she began to dress more provocatively in order to get his attention. Her new look caught his attention, and the two began to date. However, their relationship was superficial and short-lived. Manny figured out that Sully didn't really care about her and was only with her for her looks when he stood her up at a party. Manny was not heartbroken for long though, as she immidiately moved on to Craig Manning.
Season 3In U Got the Look, Manny develops a crush on Sully and decides to change her image to get him and other guys to notice her. Sully takes a liking to Manny when she starts wearing sexy clothes, and decides to ask her out on a date. He is also very rude to J.T. when he attempts to ask Manny out. J.T. is crushed when Manny chooses Sully over him.
In Should I Stay or Should I Go?, Sully is confronted by Manny when she didn't receive a rose from him. He nonchalantly gives her back the rose she bought for him and tells her to "pretend it came from him". When Manny brings up the fact that Craig Manning bought a dozen roses for his girlfriend Ashley Kerwin, Sully smugly says that Craig is a "sucker" and then walks away, leaving Manny disappointed. This episode was the last appearance of Sully.
- Sully was Manny's first boyfriend.
- Start Up: U Got the Look (303)
- Broke Up: Should I Stay Or Should I Go? (307)
- Reason: Sully was inattentive towards her and her affections quickly shifted to Craig.