In This Charming Man, due to the other driving classes being full, Mr. Falcone is placed as their driving instructor. Upon first sight of him, Paige develops a crush on him, and she becomes nervous in presence, resulting in her driving poorly. Spinner and Jimmy proceed to tease Paige about the next day, and Hazel whispers to her in class that rumor is that Mr. Falcone is quite the looker, though Paige tells her that she hadn't noticed. Hazel figures out that Paige is attracted to their teacher, and she subtly points this out in front of their friends.
Spinner becomes upset when he realizes she likes him, and angrily walks away from Paige. While Spinner is on the driving course, he angrily lashes out at Mr. Falcone, and Spinner ends up crashing the student driver's vehicle due to his lack of attention to the road. Paige later apologizes to Spinner, and he reveals he switched their driving instructor back to their previous one.